These are seven Carmel-based real estate teams and agents with near-perfect Google ratings, ranked by a score that weighs rating against review count. We read about 30 recent reviews for each and checked their websites on November 16, 2026.
Our 7 picks at a glance
- Shelly Walters Realty Group: Sellers who want a listing plan
- Onward Realty Partners at Keller Williams Realty: Buying and selling at once
- Steve Clark Team – Compass Real Estate: Relocation and new construction
- Carlos J Higareda, Realtor: Quick sales and repeat clients
- The Carrie Holle Group: Luxury and hard-to-sell homes
- Deborah Argenta Broker: Complicated or stalled sales
- Carpenter Realtors: Indiana brokerage with many agents
Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.
1. Shelly Walters Realty Group
Best for Sellers who want a listing plan
What reviewers say: Sellers often describe careful prep before listing, from a pre-listing inspection to good photos and contractor contacts, and several say homes sold quickly even in a slow market. Fast replies to calls and texts and steady negotiation are other common themes, and a few reviews mention working with Jeff on the team.
- Family team and woman-owned business based at 350 Veterans Way in Carmel (per its website)
- Buying, selling, luxury and lakefront homes, and first-time buyers (per its website)
- Serves Carmel, Fishers, Westfield, Noblesville, Zionsville and Indianapolis (per its website)
2. Onward Realty Partners at Keller Williams Realty
Best for Buying and selling at once
What reviewers say: Many reviewers bought and sold with this team at the same time and credit it with keeping both sides on schedule. Help lining up contractors before a sale, patient guidance for first-time buyers, and an organized transaction coordinator come up repeatedly, with Jennifer Goodspeed and Tom Endicott named most often.
Good to know: This is a multi-agent team, so ask who will be your main agent and who handles paperwork.
- Team affiliated with Keller Williams Indy Metro Partners, an independently owned office (per its website)
- Buying, selling, home value estimates and seller marketing plans (per its website)
- Serves Carmel, Indianapolis, Fishers, Zionsville, Westfield and Noblesville (per its website)
3. Steve Clark Team – Compass Real Estate
Best for Relocation and new construction
What reviewers say: Several reviewers moved from out of state or out of the country and say the team guided them through every step, including builder meetings on new construction. Responsiveness, strong negotiating, and well-organized support staff are mentioned often, with Angelo Caruso named in many reviews.
Good to know: Reviews mostly describe individual agents on the team, so ask who you will be working with.
- Founded by Steve Clark in 2016 and affiliated with Compass (per its website)
- Buyer and seller support, including bridge loan services and Compass Concierge (per its website)
- Featured areas include Carmel, Zionsville, Westfield, Noblesville and Fishers (per its website)
4. Carlos J Higareda, Realtor
Best for Quick sales and repeat clients
What reviewers say: Reviewers often say their homes sold within days, and several came back to Carlos for a second or third deal or after a family member used him. First-time buyers describe him as patient and quick to answer questions, and other agents who worked opposite him praise his responsiveness.
- Licensed in Indiana with eXp Realty (per his website)
- Office at 200 S Rangeline Rd in Carmel (per his website and Google)
- Helps buyers and sellers in Indianapolis and surrounding communities (per his website)
5. The Carrie Holle Group
Best for Luxury and hard-to-sell homes
What reviewers say: Reviewers describe a large team that handled newcomers to Carmel, condo buyers, and owners of unusual properties that had been hard to sell. Help with staging and photos and good communication with out-of-state sellers come up in several reviews, and builders and repeat clients praise Carrie directly.
Good to know: Many of the reviews we read are two to three years old, and experiences are tied to individual agents on the team.
- Led by Carrie Holle, who has about three decades in the market and was the first founding agent for Compass in Indiana (per its website)
- Represents buyers and sellers of luxury homes, estates, land and new construction (per its website)
- Office at 10 E Main St, Suite 250, in Carmel (per its website)
6. Deborah Argenta Broker
Best for Complicated or stalled sales
What reviewers say: Several reviewers had a home that had not sold with another agent, a tight deadline, or a complicated life situation, and say Deborah built a new plan and got the deal closed. Clear handling of inspections and negotiations and constant availability by text and phone are other repeated themes.
- Associate broker with an office on N Meridian St in Carmel (per her website)
- Works with buyers and sellers, with a home estimate tool and seller resources (per her website)
- Searches cover Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville, Westfield and Noblesville (per her website)
7. Carpenter Realtors
Best for Indiana brokerage with many agents
What reviewers say: Reviewers praise a range of agents at this Carmel office, and relocation clients describe long house-hunting days and fast follow-up. Repeat customers who used the same agent for several moves, and help planning work before a sale, also come up more than once.
Good to know: Service depends on the agent you are paired with, so ask for someone who knows your target neighborhoods.
- Indiana brokerage that started more than 50 years ago (per its website)
- Carmel office at 790 City Center Dr (per Google)
- Offices across Central Indiana, including Westfield, Fishers, Noblesville and Zionsville (per BBB)
How we picked
- Every pick has its own Google Business Profile with an office address in Carmel, Indiana, checked on November 16, 2026.
- Teams and agents who work under a national brokerage were eligible when they have their own profile and reviews. We left out franchise office listings themselves and property management and rental offices.
- Minimum of 4.8 stars on at least 30 Google reviews. All seven picks are rated 5.0.
- Ranked by an adjusted score, (rating x reviews + 4.5 x 30) / (reviews + 30), so more reviews at the same rating ranks higher.
- We read about 30 recent Google reviews for each and summarized only themes that came up more than once.
Before you hire
- Interview at least two or three agents and ask how many clients they are working with right now.
- On a team, ask who will be your day-to-day contact and who handles showings, paperwork and closing.
- Ask how the agent is paid and read the listing or buyer agreement before you sign it.
- Ask for recent sales or purchases in the neighborhoods you care about.
- Indiana licenses real estate brokers through the Professional Licensing Agency, and you can look up a license at https://mylicense.in.gov/everification/.
Questions people ask
Are these independent agents or national brokerages?
Most are local teams or agents with their own Carmel profile who work under a brokerage. Per their websites, Onward Realty Partners is with Keller Williams, the Steve Clark Team and The Carrie Holle Group are with Compass, and Carlos Higareda is with eXp Realty. Carpenter Realtors is an Indiana brokerage.
Which pick works with people relocating to Carmel?
Reviewers of the Steve Clark Team, The Carrie Holle Group and Carpenter Realtors describe help with moves from out of state. Ask any agent how they handle remote showings and closings.
Why isn’t my favorite real estate agent on the list?
They may have fewer than 30 Google reviews, a rating under 4.8, no Carmel office address on their profile, or reviews listed under a brokerage office instead of their own name. We plan to check again at our next update.
Own one of these businesses or know one we missed? Tell us about it. Getting on a list is free and follows the rules on our How we pick page. Ratings change daily, so click through for today’s numbers.