How We Pick and How We Write

Best of Carmel publishes local guides and Best-of lists for people in and around Carmel, Indiana. This page sets out the rules we follow, what businesses can and can’t pay for, and how to tell us when we get something wrong.

Carmel-specific, or we don’t publish it

Everything on the site is about Carmel and the neighborhoods around it. If a guide or a list isn’t useful to someone in Carmel, we don’t publish it.

The answer comes first

Our guides are written answer-first. The top of each guide answers the question in its title, and the rest of the page explains the details.

How we pick businesses for Best-of lists

Every Best-of list follows the same published rules:

  • The business is locally owned. National chains and franchise locations are left out.
  • It has a Carmel address, or for home services, it is based in Carmel or nearby in Hamilton County and serves Carmel.
  • It has a high Google rating backed by enough reviews: 4.7 or higher from 75 or more reviews for home services and auto repair, 4.5 or higher from 200 or more for restaurants and cafes, 4.7 or higher from 50 or more for health and family, and 4.8 or higher from 30 or more for professional services. If a list uses a different cutoff, the list says so.
  • Businesses that qualify are ordered by their rating adjusted for review count, so a rating backed by many reviews counts for more than the same rating backed by a few.
  • We read recent reviews for each business and summarize, in our own words, the themes that come up more than once.
  • Every rating on a list is dated, so you can see when we checked it. We recheck each list every few months.

Nobody pays to be on a list

No business can pay to get on a Best-of list, to move up one, or to stay on one.

Expert guides are paid, and labeled

Some local businesses pay to be the expert behind a guide. Those guides are labeled with the business’s name, and paid partners are marked “Expert partner (paid)” wherever they appear. Paying to be an expert never changes the order of a Best-of list.

What we never do

  • We never invent reviews.
  • We never invent prices.
  • We never invent licenses or credentials.

Corrections

If something on the site is wrong or out of date, tell us through the Get featured page and say which page and what needs fixing.