These are five personal injury law firms with an office in Carmel and Google ratings of 4.8 or higher, ranked by a score that weighs rating against review count. We read about 30 recent reviews for each firm and checked each firm’s website on November 16, 2026.
Our 5 picks at a glance
- Wagner Reese, LLP: Hands-on paralegal support
- Doehrman Buba Ring Car Accident & Personal Injury Lawyers: Truck and car accident cases
- Crossen Law Firm: Carmel-based firm, wide case range
- Stewart & Stewart Attorneys: High-volume auto accident practice
- Schiller Law Offices: Frequent case updates
Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.
1. Wagner Reese, LLP
Best for Hands-on paralegal support
What reviewers say: Reviewers frequently name both their attorney and their paralegal or case manager, and say the team kept them informed from start to finish. Car accident clients describe help dealing with the other driver’s insurer and with medical bills, and several call the staff caring and patient.
Good to know: The firm has offices across Indiana, so ask which attorney and staff in the Carmel office will handle your case.
- Says it has helped injured people for more than two decades (per its website)
- Car, truck and motorcycle accidents, medical malpractice, birth injury and wrongful death, among others (per its website)
- Works on contingency with free initial consultations, and its site says fees may range from 20% to 40% (per its website)
2. Doehrman Buba Ring Car Accident & Personal Injury Lawyers
Best for Truck and car accident cases
What reviewers say: Reviewers often mention semi-truck and car accident cases and describe the attorneys as knowledgeable, compassionate and clear about the process. Several say they were treated with respect, got quick answers to frequent emails, and were referred to other specialists when needed.
- Says it has been trusted for over 50 years (per its website)
- Trucking, car and motorcycle accidents, traumatic brain injury and wrongful death (per its website)
- Office at 120 N Rangeline Rd in Carmel; works on contingency with free initial consultations (per its website)
3. Crossen Law Firm
Best for Carmel-based firm, wide case range
What reviewers say: Reviewers describe the staff as caring, organized and quick to respond, and several name attorney Russ Kooi or Trevor Crossen as keeping them informed throughout. A few reviews mention help with workers’ compensation as well as car accident claims.
Good to know: Many of the recent reviews are only a few words long, so they say less about the details of the work than reviews for some other firms.
- Main office at 4661 Lisborn Dr in Carmel, with a second office in Indianapolis (per its website)
- Vehicle accidents, workers’ compensation, medical malpractice, nursing home abuse, slip and falls and more (per its website)
- Says it offers free consultations and charges no fee unless it wins (per its website)
4. Stewart & Stewart Attorneys
Best for High-volume auto accident practice
What reviewers say: Clients often name their attorney or case manager and say they got timely updates and answers during a long process. Auto accident cases come up most, and several first-time clients say the staff explained each step.
Good to know: Some Google reviews are about the firm’s community events and programs rather than legal work, so read the reviews that describe actual cases.
- Office at 931 S Rangeline Rd in Carmel (per its website)
- Auto, truck and motorcycle accidents, workers’ compensation, medical malpractice, wrongful death and wage claims (per its website)
- Says there are no fees unless it wins or settles, with free initial consultations (per its website)
5. Schiller Law Offices
Best for Frequent case updates
What reviewers say: The most common theme is communication, with many reviewers saying their attorney and case manager kept them updated at every step. Reviewers also describe the staff as kind and straightforward, and several name the same small group of team members.
Good to know: One recent reviewer with a serious, permanent injury felt the firm did not handle their case well, so ask how the firm staffs complex cases.
- Offices in Carmel, Indianapolis, Evansville, Merrillville, South Bend and Fort Wayne (per its website)
- Auto and trucking accidents, brain and spinal injuries, slip and falls, dog bites, wrongful death and workers’ comp (per its website)
- Offers free consultations, has a Spanish-language version of its site, and says you pay nothing until it wins (per its website)
How we picked
- Every firm has a Google Business Profile with an office address in Carmel, Indiana, checked on November 16, 2026. Firms with a nearby Indianapolis or Fishers address were left out.
- We included firms whose main focus is personal injury, and left out national advertising firms and firms whose primary Google category is a different practice area.
- Minimum of 4.8 stars on at least 30 Google reviews.
- Ranked by an adjusted score, (rating x reviews + 4.5 x 30) / (reviews + 30), so a firm with a long review history can rank close to one with a perfect score on fewer reviews.
- We read about 30 recent Google reviews per firm. We do not report case results, settlement amounts or verdicts, even when a website or review lists them.
Before you hire
- This list is not legal advice. Talk with a licensed Indiana attorney about your specific situation.
- You can check an attorney’s Indiana license and status on the Indiana Roll of Attorneys at https://courtapps.in.gov/rollofattorneys/.
- Ask who will handle your case day to day, the attorney or a case manager, and how often you will get updates.
- Get the contingency fee percentage and how case costs are handled in writing before you sign.
- Deadlines to file injury claims can be short, so do not wait long to get a consultation.
Questions people ask
How do personal injury lawyers on this list charge?
All five say on their websites that they offer free consultations and charge no fee unless they recover money for you. Wagner Reese says its fee may range from 20% to 40%. Ask each firm for its exact terms in writing.
Which firms have offices outside Carmel too?
Wagner Reese and Schiller Law Offices list several Indiana offices, and Crossen Law Firm lists a second office in Indianapolis, per their websites. Stewart & Stewart and Doehrman Buba Ring list their Carmel office.
Why isn’t my favorite personal injury lawyer on the list?
The firm may not have a Carmel office address on Google, may have fewer than 30 reviews or a rating under 4.8, or may focus mainly on another area of law. We will check again at our next update.
Own one of these businesses or know one we missed? Tell us about it. Getting on a list is free and follows the rules on our How we pick page. Ratings change daily, so click through for today’s numbers.