These are the 6 independent roofing companies in Carmel that we would call first, picked on Google rating, review volume and what recent customers wrote. For each one we read about 30 recent Google reviews and checked its own website.
Our 6 picks at a glance
- UHQ Construction: Roof, siding and windows together
- Indianapolis Roofing LLC: Fast leak and gutter fixes
- Myers Exteriors: Honest repair over replacement
- Red Bird Roofing: Thorough storm inspections
- Beard Roofing and Exteriors: Hail damage and insurance claims
- The Roof Squad: Insurance appeals and financing
Nobody paid to be on this list. We picked and ordered these businesses using the method below. Some local businesses pay to be the labeled expert behind one of our guides. If one of them is on this list, it gets an “Expert partner (paid)” badge, and it never moves up because of it.
1. UHQ Construction
Best for Roof, siding and windows together
What reviewers say: Many reviewers hired UHQ for several exterior jobs at once, such as a roof with new siding, gutters or windows. Customers praise steady communication, crews that kept to the schedule and help with insurance claims. Several say the sales staff did not push work they did not need.
Good to know: One reviewer had a surprise change order once the old siding came off, so ask how hidden damage is priced before you sign.
- Has served the area since 2014 (per its website)
- Roofing, siding, windows, doors, gutters and storm damage restoration, with insurance claim help (per its website)
- Offices in Carmel on East Carmel Drive and in Greenwood; serves Indianapolis and central Indiana (per its website)
2. Indianapolis Roofing LLC
Best for Fast leak and gutter fixes
What reviewers say: Speed is the common thread: reviewers describe leaks fixed within a day or two, gutters replaced quickly and full roofs finished in one day. Customers say the bids were in line with or below other roofers and that the team helped with insurance. Many mention a spotless cleanup.
- Describes itself as a local, family-owned roofing company (per its website)
- Roof repair and replacement, storm and hail damage, inspections, gutters, siding and chimney repair (per its website)
- Office on East 96th Street; serves Carmel, Zionsville, Fishers, Westfield and Noblesville (per its website)
3. Myers Exteriors
Best for Honest repair over replacement
What reviewers say: Reviewers often say Myers suggested a repair when other companies pushed a full replacement, and that it took on small jobs others passed on. Customers mention same-day inspections after wind storms and quick, detailed quotes. Gutter guards, skylights and windows also come up.
Good to know: One reviewer described months of back and forth and an estimate showing two different prices, so get the final number in writing.
- Describes itself as a local, family-owned roofing company (per its website)
- Roofing including metal, windows, Hardie and vinyl siding, doors, painting, insulation and gutter guards (per its website)
- Single office on North College Avenue in Carmel; serves central Indiana (per its website)
4. Red Bird Roofing
Best for Thorough storm inspections
What reviewers say: Reviewers praise detailed inspections, including photo reports after storms and attic checks to track down leaks. Several say the inspector told them the roof was fine and did not push repairs. Customers also mention quick replies when other roofers did not call back.
Good to know: One reviewer reports repeated leaks after a 2025 install that took many return visits, so ask how warranty callbacks are handled.
- Describes itself as a trusted local roofing contractor based in Carmel (per its website)
- Roof repair, replacement, emergency tarping, shingle, slate and metal roofs, gutters, siding, attic insulation and insurance claim help (per its website)
- Office on Ridge Pointe Drive in Carmel; serves Carmel, greater Indianapolis and Lafayette (per its website)
5. Beard Roofing and Exteriors
Best for Hail damage and insurance claims
What reviewers say: Hail and wind claims come up often, with reviewers saying their rep inspected the roof and attic carefully and even met the insurance adjuster on site. Customers describe roofs replaced in a single day and a careful cleanup, including a sweep for stray nails. Several call the price fair compared with other bids.
Good to know: Two recent reviewers said their jobs took many months to finish, so ask for a start and completion date in the contract.
- Roof inspections, repair and replacement, storm damage, gutters, Hardie siding, skylights and windows (per its website)
- Also does commercial and multi-family roofing and Christmas light installation (per its website)
- Office on East 156th Street in Carmel; Google lists weekday hours plus Saturday morning
6. The Roof Squad
Best for Insurance appeals and financing
What reviewers say: Reviewers often credit the office team with handling the insurance side, including one appeal after an initial denial. Customers describe storm repairs quoted and finished in under a day, prices below other quotes and monthly payment options. Many mention a clean job site afterward.
Good to know: Two reviewers had disputes, one over a price increase after the old roof came off and one over warranty coverage, so read the contract terms closely.
- In business since 2016 and founded by Rob Marshall, who started roofing with his father (per its website)
- Shingle and metal roofing, gutters, siding, insulation, windows, storm damage and financing (per its website)
- Office on 3rd Avenue SW in Carmel; serves Carmel, Fishers, Westfield, Noblesville and Indianapolis (per its website)
How we picked
- Has an office in Carmel or on the Carmel and Indianapolis line and serves Carmel, and is shown as operating on Google Maps (checked November 16, 2026).
- Independent or locally owned only. We left out multi-state roofing chains and national brands.
- At least 4.7 stars on Google from 75 or more reviews.
- Ranked by an adjusted score, (rating x reviews + 4.5 x 75) / (reviews + 75), so a perfect score from a few reviews does not outrank a long track record.
- Every pick had at least one recent complaint among the reviews we read; where a complaint matters for hiring, we note it under Good to know.
Before you hire
- Get two or three written quotes and compare the same items: shingle line, underlayment, ventilation and how rotted decking is priced.
- Ask for proof of liability insurance and workers’ compensation before anyone climbs on your roof.
- After a storm, call your insurance company yourself and be wary of anyone asking you to sign before an inspection.
- Get both the manufacturer warranty and the roofer’s workmanship warranty in writing.
- Put a start date, a completion date and cleanup terms, including a nail sweep, in the contract.
Questions people ask
Which Carmel roofers help with insurance claims?
UHQ Construction, Red Bird Roofing, Beard Roofing and Exteriors and The Roof Squad all list insurance claim help on their websites, and reviewers of Indianapolis Roofing and Myers Exteriors also mention help with insurers.
Can I get a roof repair instead of a full replacement?
Often, yes. Reviewers of Myers Exteriors and Red Bird Roofing say those companies recommended a repair or told them no work was needed when other roofers pushed a replacement. Getting a second opinion is worth it.
Why isn’t my favorite roofer on the list?
We only included independent roofers with a Carmel-area office and at least 4.7 stars from 75 or more Google reviews. Multi-state chains were left out, and some good local roofers did not have enough reviews yet. Ratings change, so we recheck the list regularly.
Own one of these businesses or know one we missed? Tell us about it. Getting on a list is free and follows the rules on our How we pick page. Ratings change daily, so click through for today’s numbers.